Peggy Sue's Maui | Hamburgers, Shakes & Fries

Welcome to Peggy Sue’s Maui

Peggy Sue’s Maui is a classic 1950’s diner located in Kihei, Maui, at the Azeka Shopping Center. If you were alive in the 1950’s, you will enjoy Peggy Sue’s decor, with seats along a soda fountain counter as well as plastic-coated booths. Complete with the traditional neon lights and 1950’s jukebox that will play one of your old favorite songs from that era. Peggy Sue’s Maui is known for its delicious burgers including the Big Bopper Bacon Cheeseburger, Earth Angel Veggie Burger, and Great Balls of Fire Jalapeno Burger with Cheese as well as handcrafted milkshakes, and other tasty treats.
Welcome to Peggy Sue’s Maui!

Gallery

Reviews

So Delicious!

September 21, 2021

Amazing food! The burgers are so juicy and flavourful. The beef patties are fresh and locally sourced. Everything we ordered was so delicious! Thank you, will be back again. Definitely reccomend you try, won’t be disappointed!

Elly Benni

Hidden gem!

August 11, 2020

We got recommended this place by some friends, otherwise we would’ve never gone in there, since it didn’t look like anything special from the outside.

We were more than pleasantly surprised. As soon as you open the door get hit with an authentic diner feeling, and an amazing smell. The service was great, and we got our food fast. And wow, it was really good. The milkshakes were awesome too. I can definitely recommend this hidden gem!

Viktor Tranto Bräuner

The best part is their Milkshakes!

December 4, 2021

Our service was top notch and the atmosphere was well worth going for. Burgers and fries were super good but the best part is their milkshakes. Butterscotch milkshake tasted amazing and well worth the price. Would 100% recommend if you only have time for one stop in Kihei

Yeva Mattson

Juiciest Burgers!

February 16, 2020

Love this spot! A hidden gem in Kihei and a must stop for the best old fashioned burgers and malts or milkshakes. Super cute atmosphere with an old school jukebox. My favorite is the blue vanilla malt and you gotta try the Good Golly Miss Molly! Hands down juiciest burgers in Kihei!

Terri Ewbank

Good Vibrations

March 15, 2020

Here’s another beautiful gem that can only be found on Maui. It’s a place that’s practically been here forever. I discovered Peggy Sue’s about 13 years ago and I’m really glad that it’s still around. If you want to a fantastic burger that’s been well crafted and taste great then Peggy Sue’s is for you. I had a marvelous burger that gave me not “Good Vibrations” but a full belly as well. I suggest adding the onion rings to go with it. Trust me, You won’t be sorry. I almost forgotten the 🍨. I had a incredibly delicious butter scotch peanut butter milk shake. I missed my coffee but I’m really glad that Peggy Sue added more great additions 13 years later. If you want nostalgia with memorable food why not come here yourself. 👍😁

Richard Abilay Jr